I am writing this as a business operator in Malta’s CBD and hemp retail sector to express my serious concerns about the proposed Regulation of Cannabis Products with Low-THC Act, 2026.
I have also spoken with other business owners operating in the same sector who share my concerns about the proposed legislation and the impact it could have on the future of our businesses.
We are not against regulation. We fully understand the need to protect minors, ensure products are properly tested, provide accurate labelling and prevent the sale of unsafe products.
We support reasonable measures that protect consumers, including age restrictions, clear product information and the proposed 250-metre separation from schools and facilities catering for children, provided appropriate transitional protections exist for established retailers.
However, we strongly question whether the proposed framework is fair, proportionate or commercially realistic.
There is a significant difference between regulating an industry responsibly and introducing restrictions so severe that legitimate businesses struggle to survive.
Many of us have invested substantial amounts of money into our businesses. We have purchased stock, rented and renovated premises, established supplier relationships, paid taxes and made long-term financial commitments.
We are now facing the possibility of a regulatory framework that could make operating these businesses extremely difficult, even where we are prepared to comply with reasonable safety requirements.
I respectfully request that the European Commission examine the following concerns before the proposed legislation is adopted.
1. Unclear Licensing Requirements and Excessive Discretionary Powers
One of my greatest concerns is the amount of discretion the proposed legislation appears to give the Authority for the Responsible Use of Cannabis (ARUC).
There should be a clear and transparent legal framework explaining exactly who qualifies for an operator licence, which requirements must be satisfied and the circumstances under which authorisation can be refused.
Businesses should not be expected to invest significant sums without knowing whether they will be eligible to operate.
I am concerned that the proposed framework does not provide sufficiently clear safeguards against inconsistent or arbitrary licensing decisions.
Who will be eligible for authorisation? What exact conditions must be satisfied? Can an application be refused even when a business meets the published requirements? How long will ARUC have to issue a decision?
These are basic questions that every business should be able to answer before making commercial investments.
ARUC should not have unrestricted discretion to decide which businesses may participate in an otherwise lawful market.
I am not claiming that the draft expressly authorises refusals without reason. Rather, I am concerned that its safeguards and the limits of regulatory discretion require much greater clarity.
Every eligible operator should have the right to submit an application, receive an objective assessment and obtain a written decision based on clearly defined legal criteria.
If an application is refused, the applicant should receive detailed written reasons and have access to an effective, independent appeal process.
The proposed system should be examined in light of Articles 9–13 of Directive 2006/123/EC, to the extent that the Services Directive applies to the relevant retail authorisation requirements.
Regulation must operate through published rules, legal certainty and accountability, not excessive administrative discretion.
2. The Blanket Advertising Ban Is Excessive and Commercially Unreasonable
Another major concern is the proposed blanket prohibition on advertising associated with cannabis or cannabis culture.
I struggle to understand how the Government expects businesses to sell lawful low-THC products while severely restricting their ability to inform customers about those same products.
Advertising is essential for almost every commercial business.
Without reasonable advertising, how are retailers expected to attract customers, compete with established operators or recover their investments?
The proposed prohibition could be interpreted as restricting ordinary activities such as:
* Displaying business names and shop identification.
* Publishing factual information about products.
* Maintaining websites and online catalogues.
* Listing product prices and availability.
* Appearing in business directories and internet searches.
* Informing adult customers about legally available products.
There is a clear difference between advertising that encourages irresponsible use or targets minors and ordinary commercial communication aimed at adult consumers.
I fully support restrictions on advertising directed at children, misleading health claims and inappropriate promotions.
However, I do not believe that a blanket prohibition on cannabis-related commercial communication is the only way to achieve these objectives.
A business that is legally authorised to sell a product should have a reasonable means of informing adult customers that the product is available.
The Court of Justice recognised in Case C-405/98, Gourmet International, that broad advertising restrictions can make access to a market more difficult, particularly for goods from other Member States that are not already familiar to consumers.
I respectfully request that Malta explain why more targeted advertising restrictions would be insufficient and that the legislation expressly protect factual retail information and ordinary business identification.
3. Product Notifications and the Possibility of Indefinite Delays
I am particularly concerned about the proposed product-notification requirements and ARUC’s powers to withhold products from distribution.
Businesses importing CBD products depend on reliable suppliers, predictable delivery schedules and the ability to replenish stock.
If every product or relevant batch must be notified, the administrative burden could become substantial, especially for smaller retailers carrying different CBD flower varieties.
More importantly, the legislation should clearly explain whether notifying a product is sufficient to proceed with trading or whether businesses must wait for an additional decision from ARUC.
What happens if a business has already paid thousands of euros for stock, but ARUC does not provide a decision within a reasonable period?
Who bears the costs of delayed products, storage charges, lost sales and disrupted supplier agreements?
A business cannot operate sustainably when stock may be delayed without a clear decision deadline.
I respectfully request:
* Electronic product notifications with immediate acknowledgement.
* Clear lists of required documents.
* Binding deadlines for regulatory decisions.
* Written reasons for any withholding or refusal.
* Recognition or proper consideration of appropriate laboratory documentation from other EU Member States.
* Independent review procedures.
* Risk-based checks rather than unnecessary delays for every product.
Product safety is important, but the notification system should not become an indefinite administrative obstacle to lawful trade.
4. Financial Penalties of Up to €50,000 Are Extremely Concerning
The proposed legislation contains financial penalties that may reach €50,000 for certain offences.
For a small independent retailer, a fine of that size could result in immediate financial collapse.
I recognise that the maximum fine does not apply automatically to every infringement. Nevertheless, the proposed penalty structure raises serious proportionality concerns.
A business making a minor administrative error should not be treated in the same way as an operator deliberately selling unsafe or unlawful products.
There must be a clear distinction between:
* Serious and intentional violations.
* Repeated non-compliance.
* Minor administrative mistakes.
* Errors that can be corrected promptly without harm to consumers.
The legislation should introduce a proportionate system of warnings, corrective notices and graduated penalties, except where an offence is sufficiently serious to justify immediate enforcement.
The purpose of enforcement should be to achieve compliance and protect the public, not to impose unnecessary financial consequences that could permanently close legitimate small businesses.
I respectfully request that the Commission examine whether the proposed penalties and enforcement mechanisms are sufficiently proportionate and clearly defined.
5. Existing Businesses Have Already Invested Substantial Amounts of Money
This is not an industry made up entirely of businesses that have yet to open.
There are already established CBD and hemp retailers in Malta.
Many operators have committed substantial financial resources to their businesses.
These investments include commercial leases, renovation expenses, security systems, stock, imports, shelving, packaging, websites, equipment and staff.
Some businesses have also entered into long-term rental agreements and supplier contracts that cannot simply be cancelled without financial consequences.
What happens to those investments if a business is unable to obtain authorisation, is required to make substantial changes or becomes commercially unviable under the proposed restrictions?
Existing businesses should not be left in a situation where years of work and financial investment are placed at risk without adequate transitional protection.
The proposed framework should provide realistic compliance periods, transparent licensing decisions and reasonable opportunities to correct deficiencies.
It should also consider appropriate protections for businesses that have already invested in good faith.
6. The Combined Economic Burden Could Force Small Businesses Out of the Market
Each new requirement may appear manageable when considered separately.
However, the cumulative financial impact could be considerable.
An operator may face annual licensing costs, testing expenses, product notifications, additional documentation, packaging changes, professional compliance advice and possible delays in releasing stock.
At the same time, the business may face restrictions on advertising and attracting customers.
The result could be increasing operating expenses alongside reduced commercial opportunities.
Small businesses do not have unlimited financial resources.
Unlike large companies, independent retailers cannot always absorb repeated administrative costs or prolonged delays.
If the regulatory framework becomes too expensive or unpredictable, some businesses may be forced to reduce stock, dismiss employees or close.
This could affect not only retailers but also their landlords, employees, transport providers, local suppliers and service providers.
I am particularly concerned that the notification indicates no economic impact assessment was carried out.
How can the burden on businesses be described as minimal without a proper assessment of the combined financial consequences?
I request that Malta carry out and publish an independent economic impact assessment before finalising the legislation.
7. Restrictions Could Reduce Competition and Consumer Choice
Another issue is the potential impact on competition.
A broad advertising ban may favour already established businesses that have built customer recognition.
Newer businesses may find it much harder to attract customers, while small retailers may be unable to absorb the costs of complex licensing and product-notification procedures.
This creates a risk of reducing competition and concentrating the market among operators with greater financial resources.
Consumers could ultimately face higher prices, fewer suppliers and a reduced selection of products.
A regulatory framework should not unnecessarily prevent small businesses from competing fairly.
8. The 0.2% THC Threshold Requires Further Justification
The proposed threshold also deserves careful examination.
Malta intends to apply a limit below 0.2% for products falling within the new low-THC framework.
However, EU legislation uses different thresholds for different purposes.
For example, Regulation (EU) 2021/2115 establishes a 0.3% THC threshold for the eligibility of hemp cultivation areas under the Common Agricultural Policy.
I recognise that this agricultural threshold does not automatically determine whether finished CBD products may be sold.
Nevertheless, differences between national approaches can create commercial difficulties for importers sourcing products from other EU Member States.
For example, Czech and Luxembourg legislation contains different arrangements for particular categories of hemp or cannabis products.
These approaches are not directly interchangeable, but they demonstrate why the appropriate THC threshold should be examined according to the type of product and its actual risks.
Malta should explain why its proposed threshold is necessary, how cannabinoid content will be measured and whether less restrictive category-specific arrangements have been considered.
For non-narcotic goods lawfully marketed in another Member State, the compatibility of national restrictions with Articles 34 and 36 TFEU and Regulation (EU) 2019/515 should be examined where applicable.
The judgment in Case C-663/18, Kanavape, is particularly relevant to the proportionality of restrictions on certain CBD products.
9. Concerns About ARUC’s Institutional Role and Potential Conflicts of Interest
I also wish to raise a concern regarding ARUC’s existing responsibilities.
ARUC already regulates Malta’s non-profit Cannabis Harm Reduction Associations.
These associations operate under a framework that involves statutory licence fees and other financial contributions payable to ARUC.
The proposed legislation would give ARUC additional regulatory responsibilities over independent commercial low-THC operators.
This raises a legitimate question about institutional impartiality and whether the regulatory framework could create unequal conditions between different channels through which adults obtain cannabis-related products.
If restrictions on low-THC retailers make their products less accessible or more expensive, some consumers may seek alternatives through existing cannabis associations.
I am not alleging that ARUC has deliberately designed the proposal to benefit those associations. Such an allegation would require evidence.
However, I believe the potential financial and regulatory implications should be independently examined.
There should be complete transparency regarding the collection and allocation of fees and contributions, and clear safeguards to prevent actual or perceived conflicts of interest.
A regulator should not only act impartially; its regulatory and financial arrangements should also give affected businesses confidence that decisions are being made fairly.
I respectfully request independent oversight of licensing decisions, published assessment criteria and an examination of any financial incentives arising from the regulatory structure.
10. Potential Movement Towards Less Regulated Markets
The legislation should also consider the potential consequences for consumer behaviour.
If lawful low-THC products become more expensive, harder to obtain or less visible, some consumers may seek alternatives.
These could include products from informal or unregulated sources, or different cannabis products available through other lawful channels.
This is a possibility that requires evidence and proper assessment, not an outcome that should simply be assumed.
However, it is important because a framework intended to improve consumer protection should avoid unintentionally encouraging consumers to move towards products or suppliers with less traceability.
A sustainable legal market can support compliance, transparency and consumer access to reliable product information.
11. Concerns About Proportionality and the Free Movement of Goods
Many retailers in Malta obtain CBD products from suppliers in other EU Member States.
Additional national requirements involving product notifications, testing, market access and cannabinoid thresholds may affect those trading relationships.
I recognise that Member States are entitled to adopt justified public-health measures and that EU free-movement principles do not automatically exempt every cannabis-derived product from national restrictions.
Nevertheless, restrictions affecting non-narcotic goods lawfully marketed elsewhere in the Union should be properly justified and proportionate.
The proposed requirements should therefore be assessed under the relevant EU legal framework, including:
* Articles 34 and 36 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union.
* Directive 2006/123/EC, where applicable.
* Regulation (EU) 2019/515, where applicable.
* Directive (EU) 2015/1535.
* Relevant judgments of the Court of Justice of the European Union.
Malta should explain why less restrictive alternatives would be insufficient to achieve the same objectives.
12. The Need for Meaningful Consultation With Existing Businesses
I am concerned that the proposed framework may not adequately reflect the everyday realities of operating a small CBD retail business.
Retailers deal directly with product imports, customer demand, rent, stock management, supplier deadlines and ongoing financial commitments.
These are practical issues that should be considered when developing legislation.
I have spoken with other business owners in the same sector who share concerns about the proposed restrictions and their financial implications.
Affected operators should have a meaningful opportunity to explain the consequences of the proposed measures before they are adopted.
Consultation should not be limited to regulatory bodies. It should include existing retailers, importers, distributors, relevant industry associations and other stakeholders.
13. Formal Requests to the European Commission
I respectfully request that the European Commission and interested Member States examine the proposed legislation and seek further clarification from Malta on the following matters:
1. Whether the proposed licensing requirements are sufficiently objective, transparent and proportionate.
2. Whether every eligible business has a clear right to submit an application and receive a reasoned decision.
3. Whether ARUC’s discretionary powers are subject to adequate independent oversight.
4. Whether annual authorisation creates unnecessary administrative and financial burdens.
5. Whether the blanket advertising prohibition goes further than necessary to protect consumers and minors.
6. Whether factual business identification, online catalogues, product information and prices should be expressly protected.
7. Whether product-notification procedures require binding decision deadlines and safeguards against indefinite delays.
8. Whether the proposed financial penalties are proportionate to the offences concerned.
9. Whether sufficient transitional protection is provided for existing businesses.
10. Whether the 0.2% threshold is properly justified for each relevant product category.
11. Whether the proposed measures create unnecessary obstacles to trade between EU Member States.
12. Whether ARUC’s institutional arrangements require additional transparency and independent oversight.
13. Whether Malta should publish a comprehensive economic impact assessment before proceeding.
I further request that the Commission consider issuing a detailed opinion under Article 6(2) of Directive (EU) 2015/1535 if its assessment identifies potential obstacles to the free movement of goods or relevant information society services.
14. Conclusion
I want to make one point particularly clear.
We are not asking for an unregulated market. We are asking for a fair and workable one.
We support protecting minors, enforcing product safety, ensuring appropriate labelling and holding businesses accountable for genuine wrongdoing.
However, the proposed legislation raises concerns that go far beyond ordinary consumer-protection measures.
When businesses face uncertain licensing criteria, substantial regulatory discretion, potentially prolonged product delays, severe financial penalties and broad restrictions on advertising, the cumulative effect may become commercially unsustainable.
Many established operators have already invested years of work and substantial amounts of money into developing legitimate businesses.
Those investments deserve serious consideration.
A law intended to regulate an industry should not unnecessarily make that industry’s lawful operation economically impossible.
My concern is that the proposed framework risks replacing practical, proportionate regulation with excessive administrative control.
Legislation should set clear standards that businesses can follow, not leave operators uncertain about whether they will receive approval, when their products may be released or whether they can reasonably attract customers.
I respectfully urge the European Commission to examine these concerns carefully and request that Malta provide stronger justification, clearer safeguards and meaningful amendments before adopting the legislation.
There must be a fair balance between consumer protection, the free movement of lawful goods, regulatory accountability and the survival of legitimate small businesses.
I would appreciate formal acknowledgement of this contribution and information about any further opportunity to provide supporting evidence.
Thank you for your consideration.